Shipping: labels, packing, weight and carrier choice
Postage is the one cost in resale that can quietly erase a good price. It is also the one cost most sellers get wrong twice — once by weighing the garment instead of the parcel, and once by discovering the real number after they already agreed a price. Weigh first, know who is paying for the label, and buy it from the cheapest place you are allowed to.
Hover any underlined word for what it means — every section below opens on a click.The maths: postage and fees come out of the same number
A sale price is not your revenue. Work through it in this order every time you set a price.
- Start from the sale price. A $40 item with $8 postage you pay is a $32 sale, not a $40 one.
- Subtract the platform's cut. At a 10% fee that is another $4, leaving $28 of a headline $40.
- Subtract what the item cost you and any packaging, if you are tracking margin rather than just take-home.
- Treat buyer-paid postage as a reimbursement, not income. If the buyer paid $8 for a label that cost you $8, nothing was earned and nothing was lost — but the 10% fee is usually charged on the item plus shipping, so the postage still costs you the percentage on it.
- Never agree a discount that puts you under your floor. Run the new number through the fee calculator in the app first: a price cut plus a fee plus postage is how a sale becomes a loss.
Example worked all the way through: $40 item, $8 label you pay, 10% platform fee → $40 − $4 fee − $8 postage = $28 before the item's own cost. If the buyer had paid the $8 themselves, the fee on shipping still costs you $0.80, so you would keep $35.20 − item cost.
Weigh the parcel, not the garment
- Pack it first, weigh second. Mailer, box, tape, label — everything. The item's weight and the parcel's weight are different numbers and only the second one gets charged.
- Use a kitchen scale. Ones that read to 1 g / 0.1 oz are inexpensive and pay for themselves the first time you avoid a weight-band penalty.
- Measure the parcel too. Carriers price bulky-but-light boxes on dimensions as well as weight, so length × width × height matters even when the scale looks friendly.
- Round up one band when you are between two. An under-declared weight is charged back to you, or the parcel is delayed at drop-off. A label that covers more than you need costs very little extra.
- Write the packed weight down with the listing. If you cross-list the same item to four shops you will otherwise weigh it four times — or guess.
Packed weight bands: what changes at each one
This is a decision table, not a price list. Postage rates move by carrier and by season, so this page deliberately quotes no dollar amounts for a label — pull the live number from the label you are about to buy.
| Packed weight | What usually fits | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Under about 1 lb | Tops, tees, light knitwear, most accessories in a poly mailer | Where many labels get cheaper, so this is the band worth packing down into — but never at the cost of crushing the item. |
| About 1–3 lb | Jeans, shirts, light jackets, shoes in a box | The most common band for clothing. Check your platform's own label bands cover it before you confirm. |
| About 3–5 lb | Heavy denim, boots, hoodies, small bundles | Several platforms cap their standard flat label around here; over the cap you pay the difference. |
| Above 5 lb | Outerwear, coats, multi-item bundles, hard goods | Dimensional pricing starts to matter. Compare carriers, and consider whether the bundle should be two separate sales. |
| Bulky or over-sized | Coats, furniture-adjacent items, pairs of boots | Local pickup often beats any label — on Facebook Marketplace a local handover carries no selling fee at all. |
Who pays for the label, shop by shop
Every shop answers this differently, and the answer changes what you can safely charge. The right-hand column is what this repo's own pricing model assumes for a seller-paid label — an in-repo approximation used for take-home maths, not a live postage quote.
| Shop | Who pays by default | Assumed seller-paid label (this repo's model) |
|---|---|---|
| eBay | You choose calculated, flat or free; the discounted eBay label is bought after the sale | $8.99 |
| Etsy | Buyer pays the postage you set at checkout, unless you price it in as free shipping | $5.99 |
| Poshmark | Buyer pays the prepaid flat-rate label, unless you absorb it in an offer | $7.67 |
| Mercari | Buyer pays the prepaid weight-band label, unless you absorb it | $6.49 |
| Depop | You choose at listing time: buyer pays, you pay, or your own tracked label | $5.99 |
| Vinted | Buyer always pays and picks the provider; you get a prepaid label | $4.99 |
| Grailed | You choose buyer-pays or free shipping; eligible US orders use a prepaid Grailed Label | $7.99 |
| Facebook Marketplace | Local pickup costs nothing; shipping runs through Marketplace checkout or your own label | $7.99 |
Those figures are the shipping assumptions in libs/aicloset.js that the take-home maths runs on — deliberately conservative, so the number you are shown never overstates what you keep. The fee side of the same calculation is the approximate model published at /api/marketplaces.
Buying the label: three options
| Option | When it is the right one | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| The platform's own label | When that platform requires it. Depop-Shipping orders, Vinted's prepaid label and Grailed's eligible US orders all expect their own flow. | Shipping a platform-label order with your own label can void your seller protection, or get the order cancelled outright. |
| A discounted label you buy yourself | When you are free to source your own — eBay after the sale, Facebook shipping, or any shop where you have chosen "arrange your own". | You must add tracking to the platform's order yourself, and you carry the under-declared-weight risk. |
| The retail counter price | Only when you are already at the counter with no other option. | It is the most expensive version of the same label. Compare rates before you queue. |
Where you are allowed to choose, compare at least two sources on the same weight and same destination before buying. Discount providers exist precisely because retail-counter and platform rates are not the floor.
Packing: the materials and the rules
- Poly mailer for anything soft: tops, tees, knitwear, jeans. Cheap, light, water-resistant, and light weight is money.
- Box for shoes, bags, structured jackets and anything that must not be crushed. Shoes in a mailer arrive creased and open a return.
- Tissue or a bag around the item inside a mailer so it is not loose against the label. Dry clean or wash before packing — a damp parcel arrives musty.
- Reinforce the seams of anything heavy, and tape in an H pattern on a box so the lid does not pop at the sorter.
- Cover every old barcode before you attach the new label. A taped-over but still-readable old barcode is the classic cause of a parcel that never scans.
- Put the label on a flat surface, never across a fold, a strap or the edge of the box.
- Do not over-box. A shoebox inside a box full of air costs dimensional weight. Fill the gaps instead.
Choosing the carrier
| What you are optimising | What to weigh up |
|---|---|
| Price | Compare on the same packed weight to the same destination — not on headline rates. Light and short-distance is where the cheapest service wins. |
| Speed | Match the promise in your listing. A slow label on a "ships today" listing is a bad review you wrote yourself. |
| Tracking | Non-negotiable. Untracked parcels are unprotected ones on every shop here, and most platforms will not count them as dispatched. |
| Insurance and cover | Check what the platform's own protection covers before you pay extra for a policy that duplicates it. |
| Convenience | If the nearest drop point for the cheap carrier is twenty minutes away, the saved amount is not saved. |
If a platform issues the label, use it — the protection is worth more than a small saving. Where you may choose, compare on your actual parcel rather than on a rate card.
Hand-off, tracking and deadlines
- Ship inside the window the platform shows on the order. Late dispatch is the fastest way to lose a buyer who has already paid, and on several of these shops a missed window cancels the order automatically.
- Drop it at a staffed counter when the parcel is valuable, and keep the receipt until delivery is confirmed.
- Make sure tracking is attached to the platform's order, not just bought. On the shops where you source your own label you have to enter it yourself.
- Check the first scan. A label bought but never scanned is a parcel the platform thinks never left.
- Tell the buyer. One message with the tracking number removes most of the anxiety that turns into a dispute.
- Save the receipt until the return window has closed — it is your evidence for weight, condition and dispatch date.
Common shipping mistakes
- Weighing the garment instead of the packed parcel, then paying the difference yourself.
- Setting the price before working out postage, and discovering the $8 label after agreeing to $40.
- Shipping a platform-label order with your own label and losing seller protection.
- Buying the cheapest label and forgetting to enter the tracking number in the order.
- An old barcode still readable under the new label, so the parcel never scans.
- Under-boxing: a soft mailer for shoes, no reinforcement on a heavy parcel, gaps left for the item to move.
- Quoting a delivery speed you cannot hit, then missing it.
- Not keeping the drop-off receipt, so there is no evidence when a parcel goes missing.
- Ignoring local pickup where it is available — a local handover costs no label and, on Facebook Marketplace, no selling fee either.
One-tap copy: the shipping note to put in a listing
Edit in place, tap Copy, add it to the shipping or description field of whichever shop you are listing on.